Sarah Rothenberg's Sold properties

Welcome to your slice of boaters paradise! This 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home sits on a prime saltwater canal in Cape Coral with sailboat access and no bridges – just a quick 5-minute boat ride to the open river waters and out to the Gulf of America. Being offered TURNKEY with all furnishings and decor included, this home is move-in ready and perfect for those looking for an Airbnb type vacation rental investment or their own waterfront retreat. Boaters will love the new in 2023 composite dock with captain’s walk, 10,000 lb Gem remote controlled boat lift, and the peace of mind offered by the newer 2021 ROOF. Plus, per the neighbors and previous owners, this home DID NOT FLOOD during Hurricane Ian! Inside, you'll find an open concept layout with modern finishes and an abundance of natural light. The updated kitchen features stainless steel appliances, an oversized island, and seamlessly flows into the living and dining areas—ideal for entertaining. Relax in the spacious primary suite with illuminated tray ceilings, dual sinks, a jetted tub, and direct access to the screened-in pool area. The home offers added comfort and cooling efficiency with a 2 zone AC system, one for the main house (NEW in 2023), and the other system for the primary suite allowing you to set the room temperature as you want for sleeping without changing the entire house. Don' t forget about the added storage offered with double door closets in all bedrooms, a bathroom walk-in closet, and an additional room in the back corner of the house great for extra storage. The SALTWATER POOL boasts a double-sided WATERFALL feature, seating ledge, and ample space for lounging, making it the perfect place to unwind. The fourth bedroom, located off the lanai, offers flexibility as a guest room or home office. The fenced in yard offers security and privacy while the landscaping, palm trees, and a mango tree out back help create the tropical waterfront environment everyone is looking for here in SWFL! Tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac with no through-traffic, this home is surrounded by well-maintained, direct-access properties, enhancing both the neighborhood’s appeal and property values. You’ll love the quiet, tropical ambiance of the area and neighborhood. Conveniently located within a 10-minute drive to Publix, Walmart Supercenter, and popular dining options like Point 57 Kitchen & Cocktails and Twisted Lobster, this home is all about location, lifestyle, and luxury. Don’t miss your chance to own this waterfront gem!

3117 SE 18th Avenue, Cape Coral

$590,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Island Harbors SubDv.

Direct Gulf access and relaxing water views from this spacious concrete block home. Expensive items are already in place. New roof & impact resistant windows, RAISED & IMPROVED SEAWALL (75 ft), resurfaced concrete pad patio. No flooding in this home last year. No flood damage. **Over 2600 square feet** of living space, including the garage which fits 1 car and a workshop currently. Driveway fits 4 vehicles. Big bedrooms. Big entertainment space when lanai doors are open to the den, dining & living room. Also 4 season windows in lanai! Watch the whole family fish together from the backyard. Adjacent screened porch wired for hottub. Short boat rides to Cabbage Key and Cayo Costa. Flats fishing 5 mins from the dock. Beautiful wide canal. Property taxes based on sale price- improve this home and save money for years to come. Why would anyone bother with locks or small bridges when you can be on legendary Matlacha? Move into this 3 bedroom + 2 bath island home on a quiet street in time for the holidays. Conventional loans ok. Enjoy the virtual tour: https://youtu.be/god338R0LpU

2733 Bruce Street, Matlacha

$570,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Cape Coral SubDv.

Back on Market!! (buyer did not make deposit) GULF ACCESS POOL home located in the highly desirable Southwest Cape Coral is a MUST see! This 4 bedroom +, 3 bath home has an 2,100 sq ft Spacious OPEN SPLIT floor plan. The home comes completely furnished – TURNKEY so all you need is your clothes and toothbrush. The kitchen has granite countertops, stainless-steel appliances, pantry, breakfast bar, coffee bar and direct entry from dining area and entry into hallway to guestrooms, guest bath and laundry room. The spacious formal dining is open to living room and kitchen with unobstructed view of SPACIOUS lanai, pool and canal. The spacious primary suite has walk-in closet, tub/shower and linen closet in the bathroom. The screened lanai has pavers throughout, heated pool, comes with all patio furniture, firepit, and grill. This outdoor living space is perfect for ENTERTAINING and soaking up the abundant Florida sunshine around the pool. The 2022 dock has a walk-around boat slip, 2023 10,000 lb lift, 2023 boat cover canopy system, and large seating area. Home is close to canal intersection and is only about a 35-minute casual boat ride to river and is conveniently located close to Cape Coral Parkway for easy access to dining, nightlife, and shopping. This is a non-smoking home, 2024 Roof, 11/2020 AC 2 car garage, screened front patio, circular driveway for plenty of guest parking, and ALL assessments are PAID, In Flood Zone but home has never had flood damage! This would make a GREAT investment seasonal rental property since it sleeps 10 as furnished!! The dining room and living room furniture is new, with oversize TV!! Please click the interactive 3D video and bouncing icons! Call today for your private tour!

4519 Pelican Boulevard, Cape Coral

$439,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ Cape Coral SubDv.

This 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home in Northeast Cape Coral offers 2,003 square feet of living space with an open floor plan designed for comfortable everyday living and easy entertaining. Lightly lived in and exceptionally well maintained, the home features modern finishes, abundant natural light, and a bright, open layout throughout. Tile flooring runs throughout the entire home, creating a clean and cohesive look that is both stylish and easy to maintain. The kitchen offers ample cabinet and counter space and opens seamlessly to the main living areas, making it ideal for both daily living and gathering with family and friends. The washer and dryer are included, making this move-in ready home an easy choice for full-time residents, seasonal homeowners, or investors. The 2-car garage provides ample space for vehicles, storage, or a workspace. Situated on a freshwater canal and located outside of a flood zone, the backyard offers peaceful water views and the setting that makes Cape Coral living so desirable. A seawall is already in place, and city water and sewer are connected with all assessments paid in full, providing significant value and peace of mind for future owners. With minimal wear and a like-new feel throughout, this home is ready for its next owner. Whether you are looking for a primary residence, seasonal retreat, or investment property, this Northeast Cape Coral home offers modern construction, a functional layout, and canal views in one of Southwest Florida's fastest-growing areas. Conveniently located near shopping, dining, parks, schools, and local amenities, you'll enjoy everything Cape Coral has to offer, including boating, fishing, golf, waterfront dining, and the Southwest Florida lifestyle.

313 NE 5th Terrace, Cape Coral

$385,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Matlacha SubDv.

Discover your dream waterfront escape on Matlacha! This charming island cottage is more than just a house; it's a home filled with character and warmth. Tastefully decorated and fully furnished it has been meticulously remodeled inside and out. This adorable cottage offers direct Gulf access complete with a 10k boat lift and dock. The perfect location for kayaking, avid anglers or boat enthusiasts alike. Enjoy minutes-away access to the finest fishing spots the Pine Island area has to offer. The 3000 plus square-foot lot provides plenty of parking and room for your toys. The raised wooden deck, complete with barbecue, offers spectacular views of the world famous Matlacha sunsets. This cute cottage is not just a retreat; it's also an excellent rental opportunity or weekend getaway. The new shingle roof boasts a 12-year transferable warranty, ensuring peace of mind. Matlacha Island, known for its quaint shops and delightful restaurants, completes the picture of the ideal coastal lifestyle. Don't miss out on this fantastic opportunity to own a piece of paradise! This is the lowest priced waterfront move-in ready property available on the island, so act fast!

2662 Coco Plum Drive, Matlacha

$375,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cape Coral SubDv.

Step into this beautifully renovated pool home and feel an immediate sense of warmth and relaxation. Thoughtfully designed to combine style, comfort, and functionality, this home is your perfect retreat in paradise. Features to Fall in Love With: Newer impact windows and doors for added safety and serenity, a brand-new roof (2024), ensuring peace of mind for years to come, elegant bamboo flooring throughout, adding a touch of sophistication, a spacious kitchen that’s as beautiful as it is practical, with granite countertops, a decorative backsplash, and stainless steel appliances (featuring a brand-new range and microwave). For those who work from home or need extra organization, the inside laundry area is a standout, featuring a barn door, quartz countertops, and a built-in workspace right around the corner perfectly tailored for remote workers. The heart of this home is the outdoor space. Large sliders open to a serene brick-paver patio with a screened pool (2019) and portable spa. The summer kitchen and bar area make this space perfect for hosting friends and family or simply unwinding in privacy. Enjoy breathtaking sunsets with a western rear exposure and plenty of privacy in the fully fenced yard, complete with a dog runner for your furry friends. Additional features to consider: Security cameras for peace of mind, Immaculate landscaping that complements the home’s charm, No flooding and assessments fully paid! Nestled off the sought-after Chiquita Corridor, this home is just minutes from dining, shopping, and Cape Coral Parkway, offering easy access to Fort Myers. Don’t miss this opportunity to own a stunning piece of paradise! This home is ready to welcome you—

4104 SW 15th Avenue, Cape Coral

$315,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cape Coral SubDv.

ASSESSMENTS IN & PAID!! Welcome to this meticulously maintained 2021-built DR Horton Aria model, offering the perfect blend of modern comfort and thoughtful upgrades. Nestled on a spacious lot, this 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home is move-in ready and designed for effortless Florida living. Step inside to find a bright, open-concept floor plan with upgraded additional lighting that enhances every space. The kitchen features ample storage, sleek finishes, and a generous island—ideal for entertaining. The primary suite boasts a walk-in closet and ensuite bath, while two additional bedrooms offer flexibility for family, guests, or a home office. Outside, the extra-long paver driveway provides plenty of parking, and the lush landscaping creates a welcoming curb appeal. With great storage throughout, this home is as functional as it is beautiful. Don’t miss your chance to own this exceptional property—schedule your showing today!

5 NW 8th Place, Cape Coral

$285,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cape Coral SubDv.

Welome to the neighborhood! Solid roof! Newer AC and Water Heater! Completely remodeled with furniture included! Located in the X Flood zone and a lifestyle where you will be surrounded by caring, thoughtful neighbors and a true sense of comunity, manicured lawns and pride of ownership. You won't find another property like this one! Enjoy endless hours of entertainment with the beautiful koi pond that is the heart of the backyard, bringing life, movement, and a little magic to your outdoor space. Colorful koi fish glide through the water, weaving between blooming lily pads, while a cascading waterfall fountain adds a soothing touch. Surrounded by natural stonework and lush greenery, it truly feels like your own private escape. These cherished fish have been part of the home for years, adding charm and entertainment to everyday life. Step inside this turnkey furnished home, which has been completely renovated—perfect as a primary residence, seasonal getaway, or income producing rental with a strong history of success. Enjoy peace of mind with newer AC, roof, impact-resistant glass windows, hurricane rated garage door, and custom designer upgrades throughout. A privacy fence encloses the spacious yard, where an open-air pavered patio sets the scene for afternoon BBQs and outdoor relaxation. Located in a prime Cape Coral area, you’re just minutes from shopping, dining, top rated schools, and a full service hospital. Whether you’re feeding the fish, unwinding by the water, or simply soaking in the peaceful vibes, this one of a kind backyard makes every day a little more special.

628 SE 9th Place, Cape Coral

$270,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cape Coral SubDv.

WOW! PRICED TO SELL!! DESIRABLE AND IDEAL SE LOCATION WITH LEVEL CORNER LOT REAR ACCESS! No flood insurance required and quick commute East to Ft. Myers and beaches via Cape Coral Parkway. Situated on dead-end street across from Gulf access waterfront homes, the rear yard conveniently allows no hassle off street parking from side road. RECENTLY PAINTED exterior with custom designed mailbox, custom side entrance to garage and front storm shutter. NEW ROOF installed March 2021. Eat-in kitchen with tray ceiling lighting and NEW SS APPLIANCES less than 6 mos old. The enclosed lanai offers year round added living space and room for large gatherings. This split bedroom layout, formal dining room and living room with sliders to lanai makes this home an easy fit for retirement or just starting out. Separate Laundry room off gargage with outside entrance and stationary tub. SELLER'S FHA LOAN can be assumed with Seller release. Additional information available upon request. The RIGHT size home with all the RIGHT features in the RIGHT location.

Cape Coral

$269,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cape Coral SubDv.

This beautifully maintained home has been lovingly cared for and is ready to welcome its next owner. Designed with comfort and functionality in mind, this sought-after floor plan offers 3 spacious bedrooms, a versatile den, and an open-concept living area perfect for both everyday living and entertaining. Step outside to the inviting lanai, where the sellers are leaving behind stylish blue wicker furniture and a gas grill—allowing you to enjoy your outdoor oasis from day one. Whether you're savoring a morning cup of coffee or unwinding with a glass of wine in the evening, this space is sure to become a favorite retreat. With thoughtful features, exceptional care, and move-in-ready convenience, this home is one you won't want to miss. Schedule your showing today!

2816 NW 27th Street, Cape Coral

$255,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ South Punta Gorda Heights SubDv.

Welcome to a spacious and tastefully appointed 2-bed, 1-bath home that seamlessly combines modern amenities with serene comfort. Two large bedrooms, complemented by a well-appointed bathroom set the stage. Step into the gorgeous kitchen where you will find wood shaker cabinets, granite countertops, and luxury vinyl plank floors throughout. Many recent updates include two large sheds, 12x16 and 8x10, a brand-new central air conditioning system and a few new impact windows for safety and security from storms. The interior has been recently painted with neutral colors, a new septic drain field and a peroxide drip system for the well. Outdoor living takes center stage with a newly screened-in carport that doubles as an extra outdoor space, this is in addition to the fully screened lanai off the exterior of the home that measures over 23ft long. Just off the carport you will find a huge laundry room that not only meets practical needs but also providing extra storage for a clutter-free living. Convenience extends beyond the property, with close proximity to dining and shopping, offering the convenience of urban accessibility and country charm. This home in not in a flood zone.

26508 Eager Road, Punta Gorda

13040 Sandy Key Bend Unit 3504, North Fort Myers

$232,500

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Moody River Estates SubDv.

REDUCTION IN HOA Quarterly Fee and TAXES-NEW AC completed with a 10 year transferable warranty Coach Home Corner Unit with a 2-car garage in the gated community of Moody River Estates. The community features tropical landscaping, walking and hiking trails, resort-style amenities, including two pools, tennis and pickleball courts, bocci ball and a clubhouse with pool table, video room, meeting rooms and fitness center. There is a Gulf access boat ramp with quick access to the Calosahatchee River. Your new home is on the second floor, featuring high 12 ft. ceilings, expansive views of the lake with a fountain water feature The interior has been freshly painted, new vinyl luxury planking flooring in both bedrooms. The great room offers true living space for all to enjoy a big screen TV and sofa. There is den/office loft with beautiful bamboo flooring for working from home, high-speed fiber optic XFinity cable and WIFI included in HOA. The kitchen is a cook's dream, enjoy Corian counters, a 13' long breakfast bar, plenty of storage, cabinets and pantry. You will enjoy water views from the great room, kitchen, dining room, and primary bedroom. For your protection there are hurricane shutters. The primary bedroom has natural light offering water views and access to the tiled lanai. The bath area includes double sinks a walk-in shower with two closets. The guest bedroom is ready for a queen bed, with ample closet space, and the guest bath has a tub/shower and a new toilet. There is inside laundry, washer/dryer included, with additional storage and hanging space for laundry. The air-conditioned 2-car garage has additional outlets, lighting & storage. AC provides a great place to store vehicles, golf cart or use as a hobby room. There is also insulation to the garage door along with new springs. The extra-long driveway can park at least 4 vehicles. This home has only been used seasonally, never rented, and is in mint condition. The convenience of County taxes only, quick access to Downtown Ft. Myers-waterfront shopping and dining within minutes via tolley or car and no homeowner flood insurance required. The Master HOA covers flood insurance. Pet Friendly total of 2 up to 40 pounds each

13040 Sandy Key Bend Unit 3504, North Fort Myers

$200,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Osprey Cove SubDv.

Turnkey Lakefront Condo with Breathtaking Views – Prime Location! Welcome to this beautifully maintained 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom lakefront condo, ideally situated on the 3rd floor for stunning views and added privacy. Offered fully furnished and turnkey, this home features impact-resistant windows and doors, crown molding in the living area, and stylish, comfortable décor—ready for immediate move-in. Enjoy peaceful lake views from your spacious living area and take advantage of covered parking just steps from the elevator. Located just minutes from top shopping, dining, pristine beaches, FGCU, RSW Airport, and more—this condo blends convenience and lifestyle. Located in a gated community with resort-style amenities, including a lakeside pool, fitness center, billiards, library, hobby room, and community kitchen—all with low HOA fees. Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own a piece of paradise in a highly desirable location. Schedule your private showing today and start enjoying carefree Florida living at its best!

8550 Kingbird Loop Unit 638, Estero

3364 N Key Drive Unit 8, North Fort Myers

$185,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Bay Harbor Club Condo SubDv.

Completely renovated in 2021 and offering wide, unobstructed views of the Caloosahatchee River, this rarely available SECOND-floor condo combines modern updates with easy waterfront living. Located in a 55+ community, it’s the largest floor plan in the building with nearly 1,400 square feet of bright, open space. This is a true end unit, no shared walls! The kitchen is a true highlight, featuring shaker cabinetry, quartz countertops, a beautiful subway tile backsplash, and stainless steel appliances. The white cabinets are balanced by a light gray island, giving the kitchen a modern two-tone feel that really stands out, while providing tons of prep space and extra storage. Luxury vinyl plank flooring runs throughout the home, paired with hurricane-impact windows and plantation shutters that bring in great natural light. Major systems have already been taken care of, with the A/C and water heater replaced in 2025. Both bathrooms are oversized and fully renovated with gorgeous tile surrounds and modern finishes. The guest bath has a tub/shower combo, while the primary suite includes a large en-suite with a walk-in shower and generous closet space. An in-unit washer and dryer and DETACHED ONE CAR GARAGE add everyday convenience. The open living area centers around a sleek electric fireplace feature wall, creating a cozy focal point. Just beyond, the Florida room and screened lanai capture sweeping river and skyline views — perfect for morning coffee or winding down at sunset. Residents enjoy a riverside pool, cabana and grilling area, plus a pedestrian path that leads straight into the River District for dining, shopping, and entertainment. The location keeps you close to downtown, medical facilities, grocery stores, bridges, and I-75 while still feeling peaceful and tucked away. New roof just completed Feb 2026. NO SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS. With its extensive updates, riverfront setting, and standout value for a fully renovated condo, this is a rare opportunity to enjoy Southwest Florida living at its best. Don't forget to check out the virtual tour!

3364 N Key Drive Unit 8, North Fort Myers

$155,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ River View Villas SubDv.

Charming 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom condo with a 1-CAR GARAGE, offered fully furnished (TURNKEY) and ready to move in! Discover this lightly lived-in retreat, featuring an inviting open-concept layout with cathedral ceilings, opeing up to a spacious screened-in balcony with breathtaking sunset views every evening. Whether you’re seeking your forever home or a winter getaway, this bright and cheerful condo is perfect for you. A beautiful NEW riverfront park is just steps away for your enjoyment. Located in one of Cape Coral’s most desirable areas, close to downtown and bridges. The roof was recently replaced in 2022. LOWEST priced 2 bedroom condo and also one of the LOWEST Association Dues in the area. Remember, INCLUDING one-car garage!! Bring your toothbrush and start enjoying the Florida lifestyle you've envisioned in this 55+ community!

4120 SE 19th Place Unit 202, Cape Coral

5313 Summerlin Road Unit 1309, Fort Myers

$150,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Mystic Gardens SubDv.

Step into a world of tranquility and comfort in this charming 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom condo, nestled in Fort Myers' Mystic Gardens community. Imagine ending each day on your private screened lanai, soaking in breathtaking sunset views from the western rear exposure. Inside, the thoughtfully designed split floor plan ensures privacy for everyone, while bright natural lighting fills the space, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The convenience of in-unit laundry, an assigned parking spot, and bonus outdoor storage adds practicality to your daily routine. Mystic Gardens isn't just a home; it’s a lifestyle. Start your mornings with a swim in the sparkling pool, enjoy a friendly match on the tennis courts, or unwind at the clubhouse—all just steps from your door. Located moments from dining, Bell Tower Plaza, Sam’s Club, Florida Southwestern State College (FSW), and the serene waters of the Caloosahatchee River, this condo combines convenience with serenity. Whether you're exploring the local scene or enjoying a quiet evening at home, this is the perfect place to call your own. Don’t miss the chance to make this your Southwest Florida retreat—schedule your private tour today!

5313 Summerlin Road Unit 1309, Fort Myers

1731 Golf Club Drive Unit 8, North Fort Myers

$150,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ El Rio Garden Condo SubDv.

Wow...imagine a neat and clean, spacious, open floorpan, with a golf course view (at no additional costs)...all wrapped in an updated and furnished package! Make sure you schedule this unit on your list of properties today. Located conveniently to all the shopping, restaurants, drug stores, etc with easy access to Fort Myers and Cape Coral. Enjoy overlooking the adjacent golf course that is public and no additional expense to your unit. The very well kept North Fort Myers Community pool is located just 1 mile away! We think this is the best value for all included in the area....come look and see if you agree!

1731 Golf Club Drive Unit 8, North Fort Myers

503 Cape Coral Parkway W Unit 201, Cape Coral

$135,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cavendish Square Condo SubDv.

This property is a beautiful 2-bedroom, 2-bath condo offering comfort, style, and unbeatable convenience. Nestled in a well-maintained complex just minutes from downtown Cape Coral, this spacious second-floor end unit is perfect for full-time residents, seasonal getaways, or savvy investors. 12 rentals allowed per year! Step inside to discover an open concept living and dining area with abundant natural light. The kitchen features stainless steel appliances, granite countertops, and ample cabinetry, making meal prep a breeze. Enjoy your morning coffee or evening glass of wine on the private screened balcony, where you can unwind and take in the Florida breeze. The primary suite offers a large walk-in closet and en-suite bath, while the second bedroom is perfect for guests or a home office. This unit includes in-unit laundry and an assigned parking spot. The community pool is only steps away from the front door. Ideally located near shopping, dining, and entertainment, and just a short drive to the Cape Coral Bridge for easy access to Fort Myers beaches and attractions. Schedule a tour today!

503 Cape Coral Parkway W Unit 201, Cape Coral

Sarah's Recent Sales