Sarah Rothenberg's Sold Listings

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Charlotte Shores SubDv.

Welcome to the epitome of waterfront living! Nestled in the desirable subdivision of Charlotte Shores on Pine Island. This meticulously maintained fully furnished-turnkey direct gulf access home is a dream come true for boating enthusiasts. This stunning property boasts two boat lifts(10k and 15k), complete with a captain's walk, ensuring you have everything you need at your fingertips. Enjoy peace of mind knowing this home has never been flooded and is high and dry, with a low assumable flood insurance policy. Recent updates include a new roof (March 2023) and a brand new A/C system (September 2024), complete with a 10-year warranty. The home has been recently repainted inside and out making it move in ready. Step inside this spacious home featuring a thoughtfully designed split-bedroom layout. Almost every window offers beautiful water views, enhancing the serene atmosphere. The open-concept living space is perfect for entertaining, and the two sets of pocket doors create a seamless transition to the large screened-in lanai, ideal for enjoying the gorgeous sunsets only Bokeelia can offer. Both bathrooms have been recently updated to provide a contemporary feel, while the kitchen is a chef’s delight, complete with an abundance of cabinets, a center island, granite countertops, and stainless steel appliances. The garage is a hobbyist's dream, offering ample storage, cabinets, and a workbench for all your projects. The property is fully fenced with drive gates, providing the perfect space to store boats, trailers, and other outdoor toys. This beautifully landscaped yard is super low-maintenance, beautiful native plants complemented by elegant curbing around the flower beds for amazing curb appeal. Living here means embracing an exceptional lifestyle. You’ll be just minutes away from Matlacha Pass (5 minutes by boat), Charlotte Harbor (10 minutes), and Pine Island Sound (20 minutes), making this location perfect for fishing enthusiasts seeking some of the best spots the Gulf has to offer. For a beach day, enjoy a scenic ride to Cayo Costa Beach in just 30 minutes. Charlotte Shores is a hidden gem on Bokeelia, ideally situated to take advantage of all the stunning attractions this beautiful island has to offer. Best of all, buyers have the option to join the voluntary HOA for just $150 per year, granting them access to the association’s marina, boat ramp, boat docks, and park areas. Don’t miss the opportunity to live on permanent island time in this show-stopping property. You will not find a better value on the Island. Property is priced to move. Schedule your private tour today and start your new life in paradise!

5258 Genesee Parkway, Bokeelia

$465,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cape Coral SubDv.

Major price improvement!!!!! This delightful 3-bedroom, 2-bath Gulf access pool home is ready for new owners. Step inside to find an inviting, open-concept layout perfect for gathering with friends and family. The updated kitchen, featuring a spacious island and modern finishes, flows seamlessly into the living area. Both bathrooms have also been beautifully updated, providing a fresh and stylish feel throughout the home. Venture outside to discover your own private paradise. The screened lanai showcases a gorgeous in-ground heated pool, perfect for enjoying sunny days. The backyard, beautifully landscaped with mature palm trees, leads to your private boat dock, complete with a captain's walk and a boat lift—ideal for enjoying all that Gulf access has to offer. Situated on a Gulf access canal, you can reach the river in under 30 minutes. Imagine swimming, fishing, or soaking in the stunning western sunsets over the intersecting canal while enjoying your morning coffee or evening cocktail. Recent upgrades including fiberglass blown in insulation(2025) A/C checkup/sealant to ductwork (2025) a new roof (2023), a new pool heat pump (2023), a new variable speed pool pump (2024), a whole-house re-plumb with PEX (2021), and a new electrical service panel (2023). The property also features whole-house surge protection (2023), is pre-wired to run a generator (2023), and is pre-wired for solar (2023). Additional enhancements include new door locks with fingerprint, code, or key access (2023), a pull-down attic ladder (2023), new toilets (2024), and a new screened pool cage (2023). This home is NOT IN A FLOOD ZONE, and has never been flooded. This is a low traffic neighborhood with mature landscaping and close to everything Cape Coral has to offer. Don’t miss out on this fantastic opportunity—great value for all this home offers, Don't forget to check out the virtual tour!

3024 SE 5th Place, Cape Coral

$385,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ Matlacha SubDv.

Discover your dream waterfront escape on Matlacha! This charming island cottage is more than just a house; it's a home filled with character and warmth. Tastefully decorated and fully furnished it has been meticulously remodeled inside and out. This adorable cottage offers direct Gulf access complete with a 10k boat lift and dock. The perfect location for kayaking, avid anglers or boat enthusiasts alike. Enjoy minutes-away access to the finest fishing spots the Pine Island area has to offer. The 3000 plus square-foot lot provides plenty of parking and room for your toys. The raised wooden deck, complete with barbecue, offers spectacular views of the world famous Matlacha sunsets. This cute cottage is not just a retreat; it's also an excellent rental opportunity or weekend getaway. The new shingle roof boasts a 12-year transferable warranty, ensuring peace of mind. Matlacha Island, known for its quaint shops and delightful restaurants, completes the picture of the ideal coastal lifestyle. Don't miss out on this fantastic opportunity to own a piece of paradise! This is the lowest priced waterfront move-in ready property available on the island, so act fast!

2662 Coco Plum Drive, Matlacha

$380,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cape Coral SubDv.

Welcome to this bright and beautifully maintained 1,900+ sq ft pool home offering space, comfort, and major updates already completed. With two separate living areas, this home features a versatile floor plan ideal for a large family, multigenerational living, everyday living, or entertaining guests. Step outside to the oversized, private paver lanai featuring a HEATED pool and screened enclosure that was all added in (2017)—perfect for year-round Florida living. Inside, the home is filled with natural light and enhanced by updated windows (2017) throughout. All openings are shutter-protected, offering added peace of mind and insurance savings. The freshly updated kitchen includes quartz countertops and newer stainless steel appliances, while no carpet throughout provides a clean, modern look and easy maintenance. All bedrooms are generously sized and include walk-in closets. Recent upgrades include a new roof (2022), A/C (2023), water heater (December 2025), updated plumbing, and a freshly painted exterior. Everything is done here! The home is NOT located in a FLOOD ZONE, flood insurance is not required and ALL ASSESSMENTS ARE IN AND PAID! Enjoy beautiful, well-maintained mature landscaping and a convenient location near Pine Island Road, offering easy access to shopping, dining, and commuting. Offered partially furnished, this home truly checks all the boxes for comfort, functionality, and long-term value. Don't forget to check out the virtual tour!

129 NE 7th Avenue, Cape Coral

$288,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Punta Gorda SubDv.

Welcome to your dream home! This beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom oasis is situated on a generous 0.3-acre lot with no neighbors behind, offering unmatched privacy and tranquility. The spacious primary suite boasts an en suite bathroom and an expansive walk-in closet, providing ample storage and comfort. Step inside to discover stunning wood-look tile flooring throughout, giving the home a warm and inviting atmosphere. The modern kitchen features a large breakfast bar, solid wood cabinets with soft-close functionality, sleek solid surface countertops, and a convenient pantry, making it a chef's delight. Relax and entertain in style with the recently resurfaced pool 2022 and re-screened lanai 2022 – perfect for enjoying the Florida sunshine. Rest easy knowing that essential updates have been taken care of: a new septic system in 2021, drain field in 2023, updated panel box in 2021, house is wired for a portable generator, and a roof replacement in 2020 with 3rd nail for added wind mitigation and peace of mind. The lanai's flat roof was also updated in 2021, and a new metal shed 10x12 installed in the backyard in 2023 – offering plenty of storage space. This adorable home has all windows hurricane protected with shutters and is NOT located in a flood zone, making those insurance premiums very affordable. With a new A/C unit installed in 2022, this home ensures comfort year-round. Situated on an oversized lot, this property offers plenty of outdoor space for gardening, playing, or simply unwinding. Additionally, this home is a fantastic investment opportunity. Tenants are already in place on a month-to-month, providing flexibility for the new owner – they can stay or go depending on your preference. Potential of 30k in rental income per year, with current tenants in place. Don't miss the chance to own this gem that combines modern comfort, extensive upgrades, and excellent investment potential. Make this house into an amazing home with just a few decorator touches. Act fast – this gorgeous home won't stay on the market for long.

1395 Salyers Street, Port Charlotte

$285,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Cape Coral SubDv.

This well-maintained property is ready for new owners. This budget friendly home features three bedrooms, two updated bathrooms—including a professionally renovated master bath—updated kitchen and flooring and an additional den suitable for use as a home office, play room or cozy den.Enjoy the warmth of a wood burning fireplace during cooler months or utilize the expansive backyard, complete with established landscaping for added privacy and appeal. Low traffic neighborhood close to Santa Barbara and Veterans Pkwy making it a prime location and close to everything. This home is not in a flood zone, no flood insurance required, equipped with accordion sliding shutters for all openings, newer windows and doors and appliances, this home has it all. Don't forget to check out the virtual tour.

3023 SE 5th Place, Cape Coral

$279,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Not Applicable SubDv.

Welcome to Holly Lakes, a vibrant all ages community offering a clubhouse, 2 pool areas, playground, basketball courts, and recreation areas! This immaculate 2009 manufactured home sits on owned land —all financing welcome! With no rental restrictions and a super low HOA of just $103/month, it’s a rare find. The home is impeccably maintained with beautifully appointed finishes, 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and a desirable split floor plan. Updates include an A/C from 2017, water heater from 2024, and a shingle roof recently treated by Roof Maxx for added longevity, with a transferable 5-year warranty. Also features a huge storage shed (2012), carport, and a prime location right near the pool and community amenities. Conveniently located near excellent schools, shopping, and dining! Don’t miss this opportunity — a must-see property!

21610 NW 4th Place, Pembroke Pines

3368 N Key Drive Unit 6, North Fort Myers

$264,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Bay Harbor Club Condo SubDv.

Discover the epitome of waterfront living in this spectacular 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom oasis boasting awe-inspiring river frontage with panoramic views of sunsets that will take your breath away. The heart of this home is a stunning, spacious kitchen featuring dark wood cabinets and luxurious granite countertops. Step into the inviting Florida room, an ideal retreat where lush landscaping meets riverfront serenity. This 55-and-older community offers a community pool and pier for endless relaxation and stellar views of the river and downtown skyline. Storage abounds with large closets, the convenience of an in-unit washer and dryer and new impact windows for extra storm protection. Rest easy knowing your vehicle is safely housed in an oversized, private garage. Located just moments from downtown Fort Myers, an array of restaurants, and shopping destinations, this is more than a home; it's a lifestyle. Experience the best of Florida living in this riverfront gem. Call your agent today before it's gone, and don't forget to check out the virtual tour. No special assessments on this unit as the seller has paid in full!

3368 N Key Drive Unit 6, North Fort Myers

$255,000

2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ South Punta Gorda Heights SubDv.

Welcome to a spacious and tastefully appointed 2-bed, 1-bath home that seamlessly combines modern amenities with serene comfort. Two large bedrooms, complemented by a well-appointed bathroom set the stage. Step into the gorgeous kitchen where you will find wood shaker cabinets, granite countertops, and luxury vinyl plank floors throughout. Many recent updates include two large sheds, 12x16 and 8x10, a brand-new central air conditioning system and a few new impact windows for safety and security from storms. The interior has been recently painted with neutral colors, a new septic drain field and a peroxide drip system for the well. Outdoor living takes center stage with a newly screened-in carport that doubles as an extra outdoor space, this is in addition to the fully screened lanai off the exterior of the home that measures over 23ft long. Just off the carport you will find a huge laundry room that not only meets practical needs but also providing extra storage for a clutter-free living. Convenience extends beyond the property, with close proximity to dining and shopping, offering the convenience of urban accessibility and country charm. This home in not in a flood zone.

26508 Eager Road, Punta Gorda

3364 N Key Drive Unit 8, North Fort Myers

$185,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ Bay Harbor Club Condo SubDv.

Completely renovated in 2021 and offering wide, unobstructed views of the Caloosahatchee River, this rarely available SECOND-floor condo combines modern updates with easy waterfront living. Located in a 55+ community, it’s the largest floor plan in the building with nearly 1,400 square feet of bright, open space. This is a true end unit, no shared walls! The kitchen is a true highlight, featuring shaker cabinetry, quartz countertops, a beautiful subway tile backsplash, and stainless steel appliances. The white cabinets are balanced by a light gray island, giving the kitchen a modern two-tone feel that really stands out, while providing tons of prep space and extra storage. Luxury vinyl plank flooring runs throughout the home, paired with hurricane-impact windows and plantation shutters that bring in great natural light. Major systems have already been taken care of, with the A/C and water heater replaced in 2025. Both bathrooms are oversized and fully renovated with gorgeous tile surrounds and modern finishes. The guest bath has a tub/shower combo, while the primary suite includes a large en-suite with a walk-in shower and generous closet space. An in-unit washer and dryer and DETACHED ONE CAR GARAGE add everyday convenience. The open living area centers around a sleek electric fireplace feature wall, creating a cozy focal point. Just beyond, the Florida room and screened lanai capture sweeping river and skyline views — perfect for morning coffee or winding down at sunset. Residents enjoy a riverside pool, cabana and grilling area, plus a pedestrian path that leads straight into the River District for dining, shopping, and entertainment. The location keeps you close to downtown, medical facilities, grocery stores, bridges, and I-75 while still feeling peaceful and tucked away. New roof just completed Feb 2026. NO SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS. With its extensive updates, riverfront setting, and standout value for a fully renovated condo, this is a rare opportunity to enjoy Southwest Florida living at its best. Don't forget to check out the virtual tour!

3364 N Key Drive Unit 8, North Fort Myers

Recently Closed Listings